Tips to Avoid Broker Scams: 6 Red Flags Before You Sign Up
Quick answer
Avoid brokers that (1) have NO official regulation, (2) promise guaranteed/fixed profits, (3) make withdrawals difficult, (4) pressure you to deposit fast, (5) have a vague address & entity, and (6) use Ponzi/chain-referral schemes. Always check the license number on the regulator's official site (FCA/CySEC/Bappebti) before signing up.
1. No official regulation
This is the most fatal sign. A legit broker always has a license number from an authority (FCA, CySEC, ASIC, FSCA, or Bappebti for Indonesia). If a site just says 'regulated' without naming the body & number, it's vague.
How to check: open the regulator's site, enter the license number, confirm the entity & name match.
2. Promises of guaranteed profit
No honest broker guarantees profit. Trading always carries loss risk. If someone says 'capital safe, guaranteed 5%/month', that's pure fraud.
3. Withdrawals made difficult
Scam brokers usually accept deposits easily, but when you withdraw — endless excuses: 'account frozen', 'must deposit again', 'high fee'. Small test: try withdrawing a portion early on.
4. Pressure to deposit fast
Aggressive telemarketing 'promo ends today, deposit now' is a pressure tactic. A regulated broker won't force you. Take your time to research first.
5. Vague address & entity
Check who owns the company, in which country, and whether the office address is real or just a PO box. Regulated brokers are transparent about their legal entity.
6. Ponzi / chain-referral schemes
If your main income comes from inviting friends rather than trading, beware. That's a pyramid model, not a broker. Normal referral commission is fine, but 'passive income from recruiting' = red flag.
How to sign up safely
Use the brokers we review on /brokers — all are regulated & we state their regulation openly. Verify yourself via the regulator's site before depositing.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
How do I check a regulated Indonesian broker (Bappebti)?
Open the official Bappebti site (bappebti.go.id) → list of licensed futures brokers. Match the company name & license number. If it's not on the list, don't sign up.
Is referral commission a scam?
No. A normal, transparent referral commission is fine (we use it on this site). What's a scam is a pyramid scheme promising passive income from recruiting without real trading.
Can Indonesian traders use overseas brokers?
Yes, as long as they're regulated by tier-1 authorities (FCA/CySEC/ASIC/FSCA). But funds aren't protected by Bappebti. Always research and deposit only what you can afford.
Ready to choose a broker?
Compare Brokers →